I always thought I had a very good judge of which TV shows (and films) are going to be winners and which ones losers.I was watching and enjoying the first seasons of 24, Arrested Development, 30 Rock and Weeds when everyone else was ignoring.
Every Fall/Spring season when the NEW prime time lineups are announced. I go through lists, and based on the show descriptions start to formulate my opinion. Of course commercials and smart billboards also played their fair share in convincing me to tune in.
So this year I decided to do an experiment. I’m going to try and predict the success of a show. First I rate the show based on it’s decription or promo. Then, I’ll do a follow up post after the show has aired to see if I make the decision to set my DVR to SEASON PASS.
In May 2010 I will see if any of my predictions were right. I call this STUDS AND DUDS of the Fall 2009 Network Primetime Schedule.
I tend to have a high opinion when it comes to QUALITY of CONTENT but just because I don’t like it, doesn’t mean it won’t be a hit with the general Gossip Girl, Grey’s and CSI audiences.

Thursday, Sept. 8.
(CW) 9PM. Melrose Place : You couldn’t pay me to watch this one. Prediction: It will make it to season 2 just like it’s cohort Beverly Hills 90210. SUPERFICIAL STUD.
Wednesday, Sept. 9
Glee, 9 p.m. (Fox) Although I CAN’T STAND anything High School Musical, I was technically a Thespian in High School (the kind that hung the lights and painted the set) so I DID watch the preview of the pilot episode back in May. It will be a hit. I probably won’t DVR-it. STUD
Thursday, Sept. 10
The Vampire Diaries, 8 p.m. (CW). I love vampires. I’m just starting to get sick of them. Do we really need more Vampires? What about a Teen Wolf series? DUD.
Monday, Sept. 14 10pm. Jay Leno Show. (NBC) STUD.
Wednesday, Sept. 16
The Beautiful Life, 9 p.m. (CW). Ugh Mischa Barton. I thought she was gone forever. I guess she now has a show that parallels elements of her own life…is this a life imitates art or art imitates life scenario? Looks like a DUD of a show but Models & Mischa seem like a recipe for trash, really good TV trash.
September 17th 9:30pm (NBC)
Community, 9:30 p.m. (NBC) – I already set my DVR. The premise and the credits (Dan Harmon (”The Sarah Silverman Program”) and Joe and Anthony Russo (”Arrested Development”) make this a MUST SEE PREIMERE. Although it has the potential of fooling us all like a great cast in a BAD movie like Death to Smootchy or http://www.premiere.com/Feature/17-Bad-Movies-With-Great-Casts.
September 20th
Bored to Death, 9:30 pm (HBO) Jason Schwartzman, Ted Danson and Zach Gallifiankis. This eclectic cast seems perfect for this series. STUD. (Oops this is HBO!)
September 21st
Accidentally on Purpose, 8:30 p.m. (CBS). Cougar Town meets Friends meets the Office? I have only ever liked Jenna Elfman in Keeping the Faith. DUD.
Tuesday, Sept. 22
The Forgotten, 10 p.m. (ABC). What was the name of the show Christian Slater starred in last year? Seems that was also forgotten. DUD.
The Good Wife, 10 p.m. (CBS). Was never a Julianna Margulies fan but moms and 30+s females will probably enjoy this show. DUD.
Wednesday, Sept. 23
Mercy, 8 p.m. (NBC). Oh NBC, have you been watching Nurse Jackie? Cause I have and it’s pretty great. Can Mercy compete? Probably cause it’s on Network TV and a lot of people didn’t get a chance to see Nurse Jackie. P.S. two nurses named Chloe eh? My bet is that the Grey’s fans will flock to Mercy as Greys will mostly see it’s LAST season. Anyone still watch that crazy show?
Modern Family, 9 p.m (ABC) . Al Bundy returns to Network TV! Is Christopher Guess Directing? Interesting concept. A mockumentary about three families of different “shapes and sizes”. I’m on the limb with this one.
Cougar Town, 9:30 p.m. (ABC)
The name sounds like a big giant joke. Can Courtney carry my interest as a main character of a show? DUD.
Finally Oct 15th 30 Rock. The pressure is on. Year three will it be as strong as the first two? I love you 30 Rock, please, please don’t turn into THE OFFICE.
** So there you have it. My initial review of the fall lineup prior to seeing the primere episdes. I will be sure to watch as much as I can and update my predictions.
** Please note, that this is NOT the FULL lineup of ALL The FALL 2009 TV Shows** I can only watch so much TV.
** This list also doesn’t include any “reality” TV or “cable” TV.